
Sunday, 11 April 2010
Opportunistic Tiger Sad-vertising

Thursday, 28 May 2009
Swedish Advertising Effectiveness Debate

The finest planners in Sweden, including the wonderful Johan Ostlund of DDB Stockholm, have sensibly decided to have a debate about effectiveness, in order to inject some life and longing and good sense into the country's "100 Watt" effectiveness awards.
Saturday, 2 May 2009
A cheer led for Andy Whitlock

Thursday, 9 April 2009
Essay in Campaign - "We believe the people should control the means of branding"

I'm lucky enough to have my IPA Diploma essay published in Campaign this week. If you get a chance, have a read... it's a fictional guesstimate at what the future looks like for brands... given trends for collectivisation, ethics and "We-actualisation" as I put it.
It was written in July 2008, so you'll see that not everything has come true so far. Enjoy it & I'd be interested to hear any thoughts.
There's a scan of the published article here (thanks Franjse)...
http://a.nnotate.com/php/pdfnotate.php?d=2009-04-09&c=cUvggjKQ&upl=1#page1
And this link should take you to a good quality pdf, though not final version... has mistakes in the charts, etc.
http://a.nnotate.com/php/pdfnotate.php?d=2009-04-09&c=jDGCHDOd&upl=1#page1

Monday, 16 June 2008
Emotion - a familiar friend we hardly know

Greetings from Berlin.
I don't know why, but I've decided to spend the summer here. About this time last year I visited Berlin for three days and such was the impression made on me by the city and its unique inhabitants that I very nearly never made it home.
Well I wasn't ballsy enough to be THAT spontaneous, but I am rather chuffed to have made it here eventually. Much as I love the city I've called home for the last four years, the bohemian principled sloth and affordable everything of Berlin makes it a charming antidote to the hectic, runaway relentlessness of London.
Anyway, the only reason I'm checking in is to let you know that this month's Admap carries another little article by myself about Emotion. This time it's not just about 'negative' emotions, but the full gamut of affective experience (as superficially indicated by Pollack's grid of facial emotions below) and the question of whether we really know what we're saying or doing when it comes to 'emotion' in advertising.
On both counts, I think we haven't a clue.
If you get to read it, I hope you find it enjoyable or worthwhile - much of it may be self-consciously provocative nonsense, but I'd love to hear any thoughts anyway.
I'll post the article here if I can figure out how to do so.
UPDATE - here's the link: http://www.admapmagazine.com/pdfs/0608_article.pdf
Sunday, 30 March 2008
8 months later...

In June 2007, along with 15 other bright-eyed advertising peeps about 5-8 years into the industry, I committed the next 15 months of my weekends to reading all the best thinking our industry has ever felt important enough to put into print (and that's a lot...more than a Masters-worth of reading)... spitting some out along the way, trying in vain to digest other morsels, and greedily allowing the great majority of it to nourish me and turn me into an altogether better-rounded and more convincing advertising practitioner.
The best bit (and the real reason I've not been here) is that I've had to use up all my words writing essays with original and compelling points of view on everything I've read... Comms Planning, Metrics, Consumers, Brands and Creativity... I've now got an opinion on everything, my brain hurts and I'm terrible company in the pub.
It's been magic, the true academic in me has had a field day. I just wish I could do the IPA Excellence Diploma as a full-time job...and I wish everyone else in the industry got to do it too, because frankly it's scary what we don't know. And it's scary how many of us get by without reading the important treasures some great minds have left for us. We've been driving advertising without a licence...and how we're not in a heap at the bottom of some dusty ravine, I do not know.
Thursday, 2 August 2007
Mr. Bergman, even your ads were dark


It's really quite impressive for 1951, lots of startlingly affecting archetypal images. You can see all the "Bris Soap" ads here.
RIP Ingmar Bergman (1918 - 2007)
Tuesday, 24 July 2007
The First Sad-vertising War: Nike vs Adidas


Wednesday, 11 July 2007
Sadly blows the wind...
If only PSFK had got the link to my blog right and not sent countless miserables to the more slapstick unhyphenated version of sadvertising. Sorry, my namesake, I hope you can cheer them up.
Friday, 13 April 2007
Planning announces itself in Sweden


Monday, 9 April 2007
100 Greatest Tearjerkers... and not an ad amongst them


Wednesday, 7 March 2007
Lizard Love Story - sad or funny?

Wednesday, 28 February 2007
Two cries and a packet of crisps, please


Surely this Crying Boom can't simply be a foible of Japanese culture? I wonder if it will ever spread to the West? And I would love to know if Japanese ads have gotten more weepy since the boom began... let me know if you come across any.
Saturday, 24 February 2007
"Mom, my love for you will never be 'laid-of'".
"Here’s an example of a successful ad for an FMCG brand using ‘a confusion of positive & negative emotions’ (as David calls it), though I’d say the dominant emotions are more negative.
http://soapbox.msn.com/video.aspx?vid=b70a11a5-597d-4baa-ab48-fd011af0e8be
Diaopai is a local Chinese detergent powder brand, and in the late 90s used (very bravely, I feel) the scenario where factory workers were being laid-off.
The underlying emotions in this ad are one of sadness, guilt and anger, which the laid-off mother faces as her child ‘grows up’ and does the washing, and then writes a note saying “mom, my love for you will never be ‘laid-off’”. Again, this is not a ‘purely’ negative ad as you can sense the feeling of pride and family bonding in the mother. And Diaopai acts as the catalyst for this bonding.
Quite beautifully, they also managed to weave in a ‘value proposition’ into the product window where they talk about & show ‘using only a little’."
Predominantly negative, "extremely effective"
Praveen sums up...
"The ad was extremely effective, and Diaopai captured nearly a third of the market, despite charging a slight premium over other brands."
True to form, Nigel suggests that the ad does have a "positive resolution" because "we feel the mother's love at the end". Yes, there is a degree of resolution - if it was a piece of music it would be the kind of incomplete cadence that ends one movement and welcomes the beginning of another. If it was a film or a book, it would denote the ending of a chapter. But it does not feel like a full resolution. And it does not feel entirely positive either. We see an expression of the mother's stress and worry for her child's future. We see how close they are. At best we see catharsis. But their circumstances haven't changed - they were probably as close before and we have no reason to believe the mother won't remain unemployed.
Resolution may have value. But this highly effective ad reminds us that resolution doesn't have to be complete. And nor does it have to be completely positive.
Wednesday, 21 February 2007
The sad life of a great pretender - new VW ad from DDB London

Saturday, 17 February 2007
Home Depot make Sads in the USA
Dan Ng recently tipped me off that The New York Times had covered a new campaign by Home Depot in the USA which "taps into the weepy side of reality TV". The article, by Stuart Elliott, describes the campaign as a cross between a reality TV series 'Extreme Makeover: Home Edition' and "commercials for Hallmark Cards"
Elliott says "the intense emotions generated by reality TV, as well as talk shows like Oprah Winfrey’s, are largely because of their focus on so-called real people, prompting marketers like Frito-Lay, Geico, Home Depot and Sears to climb aboard the reality bandwagon".
The lead ad is especially weepy and involves a single mother:
“My name is Amy. Eleven years ago, I was a shy, new single mom, trying to just kind of make it on my own. When I bought the house, and I’ll try not to cry on this one, 15 days after I bought the house, my dad died.”
“He remodeled every house we lived in,” she adds, crying.
Another ad involves an occupational therapist who's been helping her patient (who had suffered a brain anneurism) to remodel her home.
“It takes a lot of courage for someone to get back into their life again,” Tammy says of Phyllis, choking up. “Because of that, Phyllis will always be a hero to me.”
You can see all the stories here.


Some of my English colleagues have found the ads a little over the top, perhaps even manipulative, breaking the implicit contract between consumer and seller (i.e. "I will watch your ad if you are straight with me and just tell me why I should buy the product"). But the Director of the ads, Jeff Bednarz, would defend against accussations of manipulation...
“I think people right now are looking for honesty,” Mr. Bednarz said of consumers, adding: “We are so educated now in watching TV that you know when someone’s being honest, when it’s coming from the heart. As long as you’re pure about it, and not trying to stage it, the honesty will come through.”
I think this campaign is interesting. Although a British audience might need something more subtle, akin in tone to the BT ads that have aired in the last couple of years with the "modern" family. I could only find this example which is cheery, crammed with product message and lacking in tension compared to the others.
Tuesday, 13 February 2007
If you feel anything, vote...

Sunday, 11 February 2007
"Emo"... the kids need an emotional fix




Monday, 5 February 2007
It's easy to do sad-vertising for insurance and telecommunications...

The nobility of melancholy... or... it's ok to be sad in Russia

I watched a great documentary on Tchaikovsky the other night (clever old BBC4). Of particular interest was a brilliant concert pianist named Natascha. She spoke of Tchaikovsky's music being wonderful for its nobility, its tragedy and its melancholy. And with great pride she went on to say... "there are no happy bits in Russian music... ever". All that noble melancholy was apparently "in our genes".
Now I have only limited knowledge of Russian culture, but what she says rings true… I can’t think of one book, one symphony, one pop song that is Russian and anything other than sad.
I was reminded of a chat I had in the summer with Anton, the Head of Planning at McCann Moscow. He was very at home with the idea of sad-vertising and described a recent Coke ad that involved a bear and a sad story of some description. I forget the details, but a sad bear story is very different to what you might expect from Coke… and certainly not something you’d expect to find in American ads.
You can see where I'm going... perhaps the appetite for emotionally complex ads is culture-bound? Consider the infinite rumours of different countries having different film endings. Napoleon Dynamite in the USA ends with a happy wedding... in Europe it ends with a non-descript and rather pathetic table-tennis match.

I know emotion is universally experienced and expressed the same way, but the cultural filters that influence when and to what degree it’s permissible to express emotion, doubtless vary.
So, I wonder which country is most fond of sprinkling negative emotions in with their positive?And which country makes the most sad ads?

